V2.1.3 - Problem with FE mesh based selections

In v2.1.3 it’s currently not possible for me to select individual nodes for creating reference points or coordinate systems, as long as they are not referenced by geometry vertices:

213

previous versions:

211

I think it’s clear because now in v2.1.3 we have the new window for geometry based selection and guess we need to click on “More” to open the FE based selection window, but unfortunately this button is greyed out.

Same problem when trying to create sections (or BCs/loads) with region type “Selection” for imported mesh files:

section

Switching between “Selection by location” and “Selection by ID” does not help.

Thanks for the report. There is a nasty selection bug in this version. I will fix it as soon as possible and release a fixed version.

Can you confirm this problem is gone in the latest PrePoMax version?

Yes I couldn’t find a problem. I just wonder, why from all constraint types only for Rigid body the “More” button to mesh based selection is still greyed out. A feature? :slight_smile:

g

Well, it is not a bug.

I will try to explain. The rigid body constraint operates on a node set in CalculiX. So it would be sensible that PrePoMax would use a node-set selection for it. A node set based selection is graphically represented as highlighted nodes as can be seen if a Point Spring is created:

image

I did not like this graphical representation for BCs when I was adding them, so I changed the selection to a geometry-based selection. Later, when I was adding rigid constraints, I adopted the same setting. The geometry-based selection is graphically represented as geometry items (surface, edge, vertex):

image

If I would internally operate on node-sets, I would not be able to show geometrical items as they were selected by the user graphically. So, for these items to use mesh-based selection, a node-set must be prepared previously.

1 Like

Since the bug is fixed I am closing this bug report.